Conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries

Previous studies have found a negative relationship between creativity and conservatism. However, as these studies were mostly conducted on samples of homogeneous nationality, the generalizability of the effect across different cultures is unknown. We addressed this gap by conducting a study in 28 c...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Groyecka-Bernard, Agata, Sorokowski, Piotr, Karwowski, Maciej, Roberts, S. Craig, Aavik, Toivo, Akello, Grace, Alm, Charlotte, Amjad, Naumana, Asao, Kelly, Atama, Chiemezie S., Atamtürk Duyar, Derya, Ayebare, Richard, Batres, Carlota, Bensafia, Aicha, Bertoni, Anna, Bizumic, Boris, Boussena, Mahmoud, Buss, David M., Butovskaya, Marina, Can, Seda, Carrier, Antonin, Cetinkaya, Hakan, Conroy-Beam, Daniel, Varella, Marco Antonio Correa, Croy, Ilona, Cueto, Rosa María, Czerwonka, Marta, Czub, Marcin, Donato, Silvia, Dronova, Daria, Dural, Seda, Duyar, Izzet, Ertugrul, Berna, Espinosa, Agustín, Esteves, Carla Sofia, Frackowiak, Tomasz, Gajda, Aleksandra, Galewska-Kustra, Marta, Contreras Graduño, Jorge, Guemaz, Farida, Hromatko, Ivana, Hui, Chin-Ming, Herak, Iskra, Iafrate, Raffaella, Jaafar, Jas Laile, Jankowska, Dorota M., Jiang, Feng, Kafetsios, Konstantinos, Kavčič, Tina, Kervyn, Nicolas O., Köbis, Nils C., Lebuda, Izabela, Lennard, Georgina R., León, Ernesto, Lindholm, Torun, Madallh Alhabahba, Mohammad, Manesi, Zoi, McKerchar, Sarah L., Misra, Girishwar, Monaghan, Conal, Mora, Emanuel C., Moya-Garófano, Alba, Musil, Bojan, Natividade, Jean Carlos, Nizharadze, George, Oberzaucher, Elisabeth, Oleszkiewicz, Anna, Omar Fauzee, Mohd Sofian, Onyishi, Ike E., Özener, Baris, Pazhoohi, Farid, Perun, Mariia, Pisanski, Annette, Pisanski, Katarzyna, Ponciano, Edna Lúcia Tinoco, Popa, Camelia, Prokop, Pavol, Rizwan, Muhammad, Salkičević, Svjetlana, Schmehl, Susanne, Senyk, Oksana, Sharad, Shivantika, Simonetti, Franco, Tadinac, Meri, Ugalde González, Karina, Uhryn, Olha, Vauclair, Christin-Melanie, Vega, Diego, Weremczuk-Marczyńska, Ewa, Ajeng Widarini, Dwi, Yoo, Gyesook, Zupančič, Maja, Anjum, Afifa, Shahid, Anam, Sorokowska, Agnieszka
Format: Article
Published: SAGE Publications 2024
Online Access:http://psasir.upm.edu.my/id/eprint/112850/
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00220221241238321
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
Institution: Universiti Putra Malaysia
id my.upm.eprints.112850
record_format eprints
institution Universiti Putra Malaysia
building UPM Library
collection Institutional Repository
continent Asia
country Malaysia
content_provider Universiti Putra Malaysia
content_source UPM Institutional Repository
url_provider http://psasir.upm.edu.my/
description Previous studies have found a negative relationship between creativity and conservatism. However, as these studies were mostly conducted on samples of homogeneous nationality, the generalizability of the effect across different cultures is unknown. We addressed this gap by conducting a study in 28 countries. Based on the notion that attitudes can be shaped by both environmental and ecological factors, we hypothesized that parasite stress can also affect creativity and thus, its potential effects should be controlled for. The results of multilevel analyses showed that, as expected, conservatism was a significant predictor of lower creativity, adjusting for economic status, age, sex, education level, subjective susceptibility to disease, and country-level parasite stress. In addition, most of the variability in creativity was due to individual rather than country-level variance. Our study provides evidence for a weak but significant negative link between conservatism and creativity at the individual level (β = −0.08, p <.001) and no such effect when country-level conservatism was considered. We present our hypotheses considering previous findings on the behavioral immune system in humans. © The Author(s) 2024.
format Article
author Groyecka-Bernard, Agata
Sorokowski, Piotr
Karwowski, Maciej
Roberts, S. Craig
Aavik, Toivo
Akello, Grace
Alm, Charlotte
Amjad, Naumana
Asao, Kelly
Atama, Chiemezie S.
Atamtürk Duyar, Derya
Ayebare, Richard
Batres, Carlota
Bensafia, Aicha
Bertoni, Anna
Bizumic, Boris
Boussena, Mahmoud
Buss, David M.
Butovskaya, Marina
Can, Seda
Carrier, Antonin
Cetinkaya, Hakan
Conroy-Beam, Daniel
Varella, Marco Antonio Correa
Croy, Ilona
Cueto, Rosa María
Czerwonka, Marta
Czub, Marcin
Donato, Silvia
Dronova, Daria
Dural, Seda
Duyar, Izzet
Ertugrul, Berna
Espinosa, Agustín
Esteves, Carla Sofia
Frackowiak, Tomasz
Gajda, Aleksandra
Galewska-Kustra, Marta
Contreras Graduño, Jorge
Guemaz, Farida
Hromatko, Ivana
Hui, Chin-Ming
Herak, Iskra
Iafrate, Raffaella
Jaafar, Jas Laile
Jankowska, Dorota M.
Jiang, Feng
Kafetsios, Konstantinos
Kavčič, Tina
Kervyn, Nicolas O.
Köbis, Nils C.
Lebuda, Izabela
Lennard, Georgina R.
León, Ernesto
Lindholm, Torun
Madallh Alhabahba, Mohammad
Manesi, Zoi
McKerchar, Sarah L.
Misra, Girishwar
Monaghan, Conal
Mora, Emanuel C.
Moya-Garófano, Alba
Musil, Bojan
Natividade, Jean Carlos
Nizharadze, George
Oberzaucher, Elisabeth
Oleszkiewicz, Anna
Omar Fauzee, Mohd Sofian
Onyishi, Ike E.
Özener, Baris
Pazhoohi, Farid
Perun, Mariia
Pisanski, Annette
Pisanski, Katarzyna
Ponciano, Edna Lúcia Tinoco
Popa, Camelia
Prokop, Pavol
Rizwan, Muhammad
Salkičević, Svjetlana
Schmehl, Susanne
Senyk, Oksana
Sharad, Shivantika
Simonetti, Franco
Tadinac, Meri
Ugalde González, Karina
Uhryn, Olha
Vauclair, Christin-Melanie
Vega, Diego
Weremczuk-Marczyńska, Ewa
Ajeng Widarini, Dwi
Yoo, Gyesook
Zupančič, Maja
Anjum, Afifa
Shahid, Anam
Sorokowska, Agnieszka
spellingShingle Groyecka-Bernard, Agata
Sorokowski, Piotr
Karwowski, Maciej
Roberts, S. Craig
Aavik, Toivo
Akello, Grace
Alm, Charlotte
Amjad, Naumana
Asao, Kelly
Atama, Chiemezie S.
Atamtürk Duyar, Derya
Ayebare, Richard
Batres, Carlota
Bensafia, Aicha
Bertoni, Anna
Bizumic, Boris
Boussena, Mahmoud
Buss, David M.
Butovskaya, Marina
Can, Seda
Carrier, Antonin
Cetinkaya, Hakan
Conroy-Beam, Daniel
Varella, Marco Antonio Correa
Croy, Ilona
Cueto, Rosa María
Czerwonka, Marta
Czub, Marcin
Donato, Silvia
Dronova, Daria
Dural, Seda
Duyar, Izzet
Ertugrul, Berna
Espinosa, Agustín
Esteves, Carla Sofia
Frackowiak, Tomasz
Gajda, Aleksandra
Galewska-Kustra, Marta
Contreras Graduño, Jorge
Guemaz, Farida
Hromatko, Ivana
Hui, Chin-Ming
Herak, Iskra
Iafrate, Raffaella
Jaafar, Jas Laile
Jankowska, Dorota M.
Jiang, Feng
Kafetsios, Konstantinos
Kavčič, Tina
Kervyn, Nicolas O.
Köbis, Nils C.
Lebuda, Izabela
Lennard, Georgina R.
León, Ernesto
Lindholm, Torun
Madallh Alhabahba, Mohammad
Manesi, Zoi
McKerchar, Sarah L.
Misra, Girishwar
Monaghan, Conal
Mora, Emanuel C.
Moya-Garófano, Alba
Musil, Bojan
Natividade, Jean Carlos
Nizharadze, George
Oberzaucher, Elisabeth
Oleszkiewicz, Anna
Omar Fauzee, Mohd Sofian
Onyishi, Ike E.
Özener, Baris
Pazhoohi, Farid
Perun, Mariia
Pisanski, Annette
Pisanski, Katarzyna
Ponciano, Edna Lúcia Tinoco
Popa, Camelia
Prokop, Pavol
Rizwan, Muhammad
Salkičević, Svjetlana
Schmehl, Susanne
Senyk, Oksana
Sharad, Shivantika
Simonetti, Franco
Tadinac, Meri
Ugalde González, Karina
Uhryn, Olha
Vauclair, Christin-Melanie
Vega, Diego
Weremczuk-Marczyńska, Ewa
Ajeng Widarini, Dwi
Yoo, Gyesook
Zupančič, Maja
Anjum, Afifa
Shahid, Anam
Sorokowska, Agnieszka
Conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries
author_facet Groyecka-Bernard, Agata
Sorokowski, Piotr
Karwowski, Maciej
Roberts, S. Craig
Aavik, Toivo
Akello, Grace
Alm, Charlotte
Amjad, Naumana
Asao, Kelly
Atama, Chiemezie S.
Atamtürk Duyar, Derya
Ayebare, Richard
Batres, Carlota
Bensafia, Aicha
Bertoni, Anna
Bizumic, Boris
Boussena, Mahmoud
Buss, David M.
Butovskaya, Marina
Can, Seda
Carrier, Antonin
Cetinkaya, Hakan
Conroy-Beam, Daniel
Varella, Marco Antonio Correa
Croy, Ilona
Cueto, Rosa María
Czerwonka, Marta
Czub, Marcin
Donato, Silvia
Dronova, Daria
Dural, Seda
Duyar, Izzet
Ertugrul, Berna
Espinosa, Agustín
Esteves, Carla Sofia
Frackowiak, Tomasz
Gajda, Aleksandra
Galewska-Kustra, Marta
Contreras Graduño, Jorge
Guemaz, Farida
Hromatko, Ivana
Hui, Chin-Ming
Herak, Iskra
Iafrate, Raffaella
Jaafar, Jas Laile
Jankowska, Dorota M.
Jiang, Feng
Kafetsios, Konstantinos
Kavčič, Tina
Kervyn, Nicolas O.
Köbis, Nils C.
Lebuda, Izabela
Lennard, Georgina R.
León, Ernesto
Lindholm, Torun
Madallh Alhabahba, Mohammad
Manesi, Zoi
McKerchar, Sarah L.
Misra, Girishwar
Monaghan, Conal
Mora, Emanuel C.
Moya-Garófano, Alba
Musil, Bojan
Natividade, Jean Carlos
Nizharadze, George
Oberzaucher, Elisabeth
Oleszkiewicz, Anna
Omar Fauzee, Mohd Sofian
Onyishi, Ike E.
Özener, Baris
Pazhoohi, Farid
Perun, Mariia
Pisanski, Annette
Pisanski, Katarzyna
Ponciano, Edna Lúcia Tinoco
Popa, Camelia
Prokop, Pavol
Rizwan, Muhammad
Salkičević, Svjetlana
Schmehl, Susanne
Senyk, Oksana
Sharad, Shivantika
Simonetti, Franco
Tadinac, Meri
Ugalde González, Karina
Uhryn, Olha
Vauclair, Christin-Melanie
Vega, Diego
Weremczuk-Marczyńska, Ewa
Ajeng Widarini, Dwi
Yoo, Gyesook
Zupančič, Maja
Anjum, Afifa
Shahid, Anam
Sorokowska, Agnieszka
author_sort Groyecka-Bernard, Agata
title Conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries
title_short Conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries
title_full Conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries
title_fullStr Conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries
title_full_unstemmed Conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries
title_sort conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries
publisher SAGE Publications
publishDate 2024
url http://psasir.upm.edu.my/id/eprint/112850/
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00220221241238321
_version_ 1816132726758047744
spelling my.upm.eprints.1128502024-11-06T03:52:51Z http://psasir.upm.edu.my/id/eprint/112850/ Conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries Groyecka-Bernard, Agata Sorokowski, Piotr Karwowski, Maciej Roberts, S. Craig Aavik, Toivo Akello, Grace Alm, Charlotte Amjad, Naumana Asao, Kelly Atama, Chiemezie S. Atamtürk Duyar, Derya Ayebare, Richard Batres, Carlota Bensafia, Aicha Bertoni, Anna Bizumic, Boris Boussena, Mahmoud Buss, David M. Butovskaya, Marina Can, Seda Carrier, Antonin Cetinkaya, Hakan Conroy-Beam, Daniel Varella, Marco Antonio Correa Croy, Ilona Cueto, Rosa María Czerwonka, Marta Czub, Marcin Donato, Silvia Dronova, Daria Dural, Seda Duyar, Izzet Ertugrul, Berna Espinosa, Agustín Esteves, Carla Sofia Frackowiak, Tomasz Gajda, Aleksandra Galewska-Kustra, Marta Contreras Graduño, Jorge Guemaz, Farida Hromatko, Ivana Hui, Chin-Ming Herak, Iskra Iafrate, Raffaella Jaafar, Jas Laile Jankowska, Dorota M. Jiang, Feng Kafetsios, Konstantinos Kavčič, Tina Kervyn, Nicolas O. Köbis, Nils C. Lebuda, Izabela Lennard, Georgina R. León, Ernesto Lindholm, Torun Madallh Alhabahba, Mohammad Manesi, Zoi McKerchar, Sarah L. Misra, Girishwar Monaghan, Conal Mora, Emanuel C. Moya-Garófano, Alba Musil, Bojan Natividade, Jean Carlos Nizharadze, George Oberzaucher, Elisabeth Oleszkiewicz, Anna Omar Fauzee, Mohd Sofian Onyishi, Ike E. Özener, Baris Pazhoohi, Farid Perun, Mariia Pisanski, Annette Pisanski, Katarzyna Ponciano, Edna Lúcia Tinoco Popa, Camelia Prokop, Pavol Rizwan, Muhammad Salkičević, Svjetlana Schmehl, Susanne Senyk, Oksana Sharad, Shivantika Simonetti, Franco Tadinac, Meri Ugalde González, Karina Uhryn, Olha Vauclair, Christin-Melanie Vega, Diego Weremczuk-Marczyńska, Ewa Ajeng Widarini, Dwi Yoo, Gyesook Zupančič, Maja Anjum, Afifa Shahid, Anam Sorokowska, Agnieszka Previous studies have found a negative relationship between creativity and conservatism. However, as these studies were mostly conducted on samples of homogeneous nationality, the generalizability of the effect across different cultures is unknown. We addressed this gap by conducting a study in 28 countries. Based on the notion that attitudes can be shaped by both environmental and ecological factors, we hypothesized that parasite stress can also affect creativity and thus, its potential effects should be controlled for. The results of multilevel analyses showed that, as expected, conservatism was a significant predictor of lower creativity, adjusting for economic status, age, sex, education level, subjective susceptibility to disease, and country-level parasite stress. In addition, most of the variability in creativity was due to individual rather than country-level variance. Our study provides evidence for a weak but significant negative link between conservatism and creativity at the individual level (β = −0.08, p <.001) and no such effect when country-level conservatism was considered. We present our hypotheses considering previous findings on the behavioral immune system in humans. © The Author(s) 2024. SAGE Publications 2024 Article PeerReviewed Groyecka-Bernard, Agata and Sorokowski, Piotr and Karwowski, Maciej and Roberts, S. Craig and Aavik, Toivo and Akello, Grace and Alm, Charlotte and Amjad, Naumana and Asao, Kelly and Atama, Chiemezie S. and Atamtürk Duyar, Derya and Ayebare, Richard and Batres, Carlota and Bensafia, Aicha and Bertoni, Anna and Bizumic, Boris and Boussena, Mahmoud and Buss, David M. and Butovskaya, Marina and Can, Seda and Carrier, Antonin and Cetinkaya, Hakan and Conroy-Beam, Daniel and Varella, Marco Antonio Correa and Croy, Ilona and Cueto, Rosa María and Czerwonka, Marta and Czub, Marcin and Donato, Silvia and Dronova, Daria and Dural, Seda and Duyar, Izzet and Ertugrul, Berna and Espinosa, Agustín and Esteves, Carla Sofia and Frackowiak, Tomasz and Gajda, Aleksandra and Galewska-Kustra, Marta and Contreras Graduño, Jorge and Guemaz, Farida and Hromatko, Ivana and Hui, Chin-Ming and Herak, Iskra and Iafrate, Raffaella and Jaafar, Jas Laile and Jankowska, Dorota M. and Jiang, Feng and Kafetsios, Konstantinos and Kavčič, Tina and Kervyn, Nicolas O. and Köbis, Nils C. and Lebuda, Izabela and Lennard, Georgina R. and León, Ernesto and Lindholm, Torun and Madallh Alhabahba, Mohammad and Manesi, Zoi and McKerchar, Sarah L. and Misra, Girishwar and Monaghan, Conal and Mora, Emanuel C. and Moya-Garófano, Alba and Musil, Bojan and Natividade, Jean Carlos and Nizharadze, George and Oberzaucher, Elisabeth and Oleszkiewicz, Anna and Omar Fauzee, Mohd Sofian and Onyishi, Ike E. and Özener, Baris and Pazhoohi, Farid and Perun, Mariia and Pisanski, Annette and Pisanski, Katarzyna and Ponciano, Edna Lúcia Tinoco and Popa, Camelia and Prokop, Pavol and Rizwan, Muhammad and Salkičević, Svjetlana and Schmehl, Susanne and Senyk, Oksana and Sharad, Shivantika and Simonetti, Franco and Tadinac, Meri and Ugalde González, Karina and Uhryn, Olha and Vauclair, Christin-Melanie and Vega, Diego and Weremczuk-Marczyńska, Ewa and Ajeng Widarini, Dwi and Yoo, Gyesook and Zupančič, Maja and Anjum, Afifa and Shahid, Anam and Sorokowska, Agnieszka (2024) Conservatism negatively predicts creativity: a study across 28 countries. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 55 (4). pp. 368-385. ISSN 0022-0221; eISSN: 1552-5422 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00220221241238321 10.1177/00220221241238321