Imposing cooperation: the impact of institutions on the efficiency of cooperatives in the Philippines

• Main Authors: Galang, Roberto Martin N, Lavado, Rouselle F, White, George O, III, Francisco, Jamil Paolo
• Format: text
• Published: Archīum Ateneo 2020
• Subjects: Institutions; Energy sector; Emerging market; Utilities; Philippines; Performance; Cooperatives; Business; Organizational Behavior and Theory
• Online Access: https://archium.ateneo.edu/leadership-and-strategy-faculty-pubs/10; https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/JABS-05-2019-0135/full/html
• Institution: Ateneo De Manila University

Purpose The purpose of this study is to answer the research question: How do cooperative organizations perform when created by government fiat in an emerging market? Through the use of institutional and agency theory, this paper presents a comparative analysis of the efficiency of the cooperative form of organization and investor-owned firms-investigating how the social–political structures in a community affect the efficiency of cooperatives vis-à-vis investor-owned firms. This paper also attempts to offer a better understanding of how government quality and organizational size influence performance outcomes between different organizational forms specifically in the Philippines. Design Methodology Approach The empirical analysis of this study was conducted among electric distribution utilities in the Philippines. Firm-level data was generated for 133 distributors, consisting of 119 electric cooperatives and 14 investor-owned companies. Panel data regressions were ran to test all hypotheses. Findings Cooperative organizations operate at a less efficient rate than investor-owned firms in the Philippines, even when controlling for firm-specific factors such as size, customer density and profitability. In addition, the efficiency of these cooperative organizations is more strongly influenced by the quality of the local government than investor-owned firms. Originality Value Positive externalities generated by the propagation of cooperatives on local communities may be based primarily on our understanding of how cooperatives have functioned largely in western contexts. Within the context of Southeast Asia, where national socio-political structures may be more dysfunctional, this paper observes that there is an equivalent negative externality caused by the tendency of cooperatives to replicate the political mismanagement of the community around it.