Metacognitive bias resulting from trade-off between local and global motion signals

• Main Authors: Lee, Alan L. F., Yabuki, Hana, Lee, Isaac C. L., Or, Charles C.-F.
• Other Authors: School of Social Sciences
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: 2023
• Subjects: Social sciences::Psychology; Metacognition; Hierarchical Processing
• Online Access: https://hdl.handle.net/10356/171561
• Institution: Nanyang Technological University

Visual confidence generally depends on performance in targeted perceptual tasks. However, it remains unclear how factors unrelated to performance affect confidence. Given the hierarchical nature of visual processing, both local and global stimulus features can influence confidence, but their strengths of influence remain unknown. To address this question, we independently manipulated the local contrast signals and the global coherence signals in a multiple-aperture motion pattern. The drifting-Gabor elements were individually manipulated to give rise to a coherent global motion percept. In both dichotomous direction-discrimination task (Experiment 1) and analog direction-judgment task (Experiment 2), we found stimulus-dependent biases in metacognition despite matched perceptual performance. Specifically, participants systematically gave higher confidence ratings to an incoherent pattern with clear elements (i.e., strong local but weak global signals) than a coherent pattern with noisy elements (i.e., weak local but strong global signals). We did not find any systematic effects of local/global stimulus features on metacognitive sensitivity. Model comparisons show that variation in local/global signals in the stimulus should be considered a factor influencing confidence, even after controlling for the effects of performance. Our results suggest that the metacognitive system, when generating confidence for a perceptual task, puts more weights on local than global signals.